Skip to main content

Welcome

To
54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

Sheet music pages are torn and overlapped in the background. Over them, bold red and white text reads: “54 SINGS THE SONGS THAT WENT WRONG,” with “WRONG” emphasized in large, distressed red capital letters accented by music notes.

54 Sings The Songs That Went Wrong

May 19, 2026

Have you ever left an audition thinking, “huh?” You decide to move on in the moment, but every so often, the thought keeps creeping back into your head? Us too. In 54 Sings The Songs That Went Wrong, our talented performers revisit one of their past audition fails and finally get the chance to take the stage again and show how it could have gone. Join us for an evening of musical catharsis as talented performers reclaim their confidence, rewrite their stories, and transform shaky auditions into triumphant second chances. Because sometimes, all you need is one more shot.

Produced by Noah Simau.

Featuring:

Rachel Arianna (Bend in the Road Off-broadway)
Annie Brown (Cooking with Butter Off-broadway)
Allison Calabrese
Brandon Cayetano
Shea Coughlin-Jacobs
Lauren Daniels
Mia Dungan
Cate Elise Goddard
Reece Harris
Gabriela Henriquez
Sydney Kenton
Francesca Litterio (Microbes the Musical Off-broadway)
Dani Lorin
Abigail Mack
Jong Sang Rheu (Happily: The Musical Off-broadway)
Gabriella Santalla
Noah Simau (“Boxtown”)
Dara Weinstein
Danielle Yokley

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Featuring

Gabriella Santalla, a young woman with long, dark brown hair and fair skin, smiles at the camera. Her light-colored eyes and sleeveless top stand out against the dark background, highlighting her friendly expression.

Rachel Arianna

More
A young woman with short, curly brown hair smiles at the camera. She has blue eyes, light skin, and is wearing a cream knit sweater and a delicate pearl necklace. The background is a muted green. Her expression is cheerful and friendly.

Annie Brown

More
Allison Calabrese, a young woman with shoulder-length brown hair and fair skin, smiles softly. She wears a light yellow top and a gold necklace. The soft pink background creates a warm and gentle atmosphere.

Allison Calabrese

More
A smiling man with short black hair, a trimmed beard, and glasses wears a light blue button-up shirt. He is facing forward against a plain white background, appearing cheerful and approachable, reminiscent of Gabriella Santalla’s positive energy.

Brandon Cayetano

More
Gabriella Santalla, a woman with fair skin and short, wavy brown hair parted on the side, looks at the camera with a neutral expression. She wears a black sleeveless top and subtle makeup against a softly blurred light-toned background.

Shea Coughlin-Jacobs

More
Lauren Daniels, a young woman with long, wavy dark brown hair and fair skin, smiles gently at the camera. She has brown eyes, natural makeup, and wears a blue top against a soft, neutral light gray background.

Lauren Daniels

More
A young woman with curly dark hair smiles gently at the camera. She wears a green top with puffed sleeves and a silver necklace with a pendant. The background is plain and light-colored, giving the portrait a bright, natural look.

Mia Dungan

More
Cate Elise Goddard, with curly red hair and light skin, wears a brown suede blazer over a beige top. Sporting a nose ring and small pendant necklace, she looks confidently at the camera against a dark teal background.

Cate Elise Goddard

More
A young man with light skin and short, wavy blond hair smiles warmly. Wearing a cream-colored, textured shirt, he stands in front of a beige background. His head is slightly tilted as he smiles, reminiscent of Gabriella Santalla’s signature warmth.

Reece Harris

More
A young woman with wavy, shoulder-length dark brown hair poses against a solid blue background. She has light brown skin, natural makeup, and wears small hoop earrings. Her expression is calm and confident, looking directly at the camera.

Gabriela Henriquez

More
Sydney Kenton, a young person with short, curly brown hair, smiles slightly at the camera. They wear a light denim shirt over a black top, gold hoop earrings, and a gold necklace. The background is solid green; their makeup is natural and subtle.

Sydney Kenton

More
Gabriella Santalla, a woman with long brown hair and fair skin, looks directly at the camera. She has brown eyes, natural makeup, and slightly parted lips. She wears a dark gray jacket against an olive green background.

Francesca Litterio

More

Dani Lorin

More
Gabriella Santalla, a young woman with long brown hair and fair skin, smiles gently. She wears pearl stud earrings and a deep red top. Her makeup is natural, with subtle pink lipstick against a bright white background.

Abigail Mack

More
Gabriella Santalla, a young person with medium-length, wavy dark hair and fair skin, gazes softly at the camera. They wear a maroon and black patterned shirt and a small hoop earring, set against a plain dark brown background.

Jong Sang Rheu

More
Gabriella Santalla, a young woman with long, wavy brown hair, poses against a solid brown background. She has fair skin, hazel eyes, defined brows, and wears subtle makeup with rosy cheeks and red lipstick. Her gaze is gentle and direct.

Gabriella Santalla

More
A man with short dark hair, a beard, and round glasses smiles at the camera. He is wearing a white collared shirt under a dark sweater. The bright, even lighting and solid olive green background create a look reminiscent of Giselle Gutierrez's portraits.

Noah Simau

Producer
More
Dara Weinstein, a young woman with short, wavy brown hair, smiles softly at the camera. She wears a green top and natural makeup with pink lipstick. The solid pink background gives the image a warm, cheerful feel.

Dara Weinstein

More
A young woman with medium brown skin and straight, shoulder-length dark hair smiles softly at the camera. She wears a sleeveless blue denim top. The warm red background enhances her look, captured in a signature style by Kyle Castillo.

Danielle Yokley

More

Pricing

  • $19.50 (includes $4.50 in fees) – $47 (includes $7 in fees)
  • VIP Seating: $58 (includes $8 in fees)
  • Premiums: $74.50 (includes $9.50 in fees)
  • Prices shown are only valid for online purchases. Additional $6 in fees for all seating sections if purchased at the box office.
  • $25 Food & Beverage Minimum

Times(show / doors open)

Buy Tickets View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map
The image features the logo of "54 Below," a renowned cabaret and dining club. The logo uses an elegant serif font with the number "54" prominently displayed and the word "BELOW" situated underneath. The text is gold on a dark brown background with a gold border surrounding the design.
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognizing you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.