Skip to main content


54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

“Payne knows how to write a song, and many of her driving ballads wouldn’t sound out of place on adult contemporary radio.” –TheaterMania

Abby Payne, book writer, composer, and lyricist of The Gunfighter Meets His Match and co-star of Christmas Spirits: Neat Edition, returns to Feinstein’s/54 Below in the A Shot in the Dark Album Release Concert. The follow up to The Gunfighter Meets His Match, a concept album that launched the 2018 award winning NYMF production, A Shot in the Dark completes the story of the mysterious Gunfighter and his tragic yet magnetic love interest, the Girl.

Payne will perform gorgeously dynamic songs from the new album with her band: JP Schlegelmilch (Visitors, Hearing Things), Paul Maddison (Constantine Maroulis, Atina Evil Queen of the Galaxy), Chris Anderson (Postmodern Jukebox, Sophie B. Hawkins), and Kenny Shaw (Dispatch, Joe Scarborough). Abby will be joined by special guests Craig Winberry (The Life and Music of George Michael, Christmas Spirits: Neat Edition), Arri Lawton Simon (The Bubble), and Shara Radin (The Gunfighter Meets His Match).

Payne puts her heart and soul into these unique and personal songs. Don’t miss this chance to hear her perform them live before they ride off into the sunset!

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Proof of COVID-19 vaccination is required to enter the club.

Past Performances

  • Thu, May 5 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map