Skip to main content


54 Below

Does the relentless sweetness of Valentine’s Day turn you sour? Are you the sort who prefers a dozen long-stemmed dead roses? Have you recently been disgraced, rejected, and publicly humiliated by the object of your affection? Your antidote to the poisonous preciousness of Cupid is here, at The Broadway Villains Party: Icy Hearts Club Edition!

If you’ve been longing to see theatre’s most nefarious and infamous rapscallions all in one den of iniquity, take a bite of out of the poisoned apple and head on down for a MWAHAHAHA you’ll never forget! Feinstein’s/54 Below regular (and longtime Villainess Extraordinaire) Amy Jo Jackson and music director Brian J. Nash bring you an evening of bewitching mischief, impish roguery, and delightfully satisfying bad behavior, brought to life by an a-list cast of Broadway favorites. The villains will send chills up your spine and blacken your hearts as they portray some of Broadway’s most notorious couples and nastiest characters – dog-hating orphanage owners, sadistic headmistresses, pirates, barbers, venomous octopus sea witches and MORE! Grab your trustiest minion, hop on your broomstick, and wreak some havoc with us at Feinstein’s/54 Below!


Krystina Alabado
Lilli Cooper
Aaron C. Finley
Greg Hildreth 
Cady Huffman 
Amy Jo Jackson 
Natalie Joy Johnson
Denis Lambert
Shakina Nayfack 
Sharone Sayegh
Ari’el Stachel
Thom Sesma
Teal Wicks
Kevin Zak 

Past Performances

  • Wed, Feb 15 :7:00 pm
  • Wed, Feb 15 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map