Jenn Colella
October 22, 2026
Jenn Colella (Come From Away, Chaplin, If/Then, SUFFS) returns to 54 Below for a one-of-a-kind evening of songs, stories, and absolutely no set list.
Joined by her longtime musical director Chris Ranney, the Tony Award® nominee takes a trip through the music that has shaped her life and career, from Broadway songs she’s sung onstage over the years to the pop songs she grew up loving, with a few unexpected favorites thrown in along the way.
But here’s the catch: Jenn doesn’t get to decide what she sings next. You do.
Every song Jenn and Chris have prepared goes into a hat that gets passed around the room. Audience members pull the songs, and whatever comes out is what happens next. No predetermined order. No carefully constructed arc. Just Jenn, Chris, a piano, a room full of good people, and a whole lot of fun!
Come ready to laugh, maybe cry, sing along, and find out what happens when Jenn Colella gives up control of the set list and hands it over to you.
Photo credit: Stephen Mosher
Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.
Pricing
- $41.50 (includes $6.50 in fees) – $91 (includes $11 in fees)
- VIP Seating: $118.50 (includes $13.50 in fees)
- Premiums: $151.50 (includes $16.50 in fees)
- Subsidized Seating: $18 (includes $3 in fees)
- Additional $6 If Purchased At Venue
- Order Fees: 10% of ticket price, plus $3 facility fee
- $25 Food & Beverage Minimum