Skip to main content

Welcome

To
54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

Gloved hands hold a sign on a red background adorned with mistletoe. The sign reads “Mistletoe & Mistakes with THE DOT NYC” in festive red and green text, featuring a bold red paint streak beneath the word “Mistakes,” perfectly capturing the holiday spirit and playful charm of The Dot NYC.

Mistletoe & Mistakes with The Dot NYC

December 7, 2026

This performance will also be livestreamed. For tickets and more information, click here.

December has a way of loosening everyone’s grip on good judgment and the folks over at The Dot NYC know all too well. Whether it’s one too many eggnogs, an office party that goes sideways, or a kiss under the mistletoe you’ll still be thinking about come January, Mistletoe & Mistakes is a tribute to the messiest month. Featuring a cast from Broadway, the soundstage, and beyond, we cannot wait to sing some of your favorite holiday tunes, some you may not know, and, of course, rehash some of the mistakes we’d happily make again. See you there… don’t worry, we already know what list you’re on.

Music direction by Abigail Gorsuch. Produced by Bryanna Cuthill, Allie Weintraub, and Renée Salewski.

Featuring:

Stephanie Ainsworth
Nile Andah
Matthew Barge
Bryanna Cuthill
Dominic Dorset (The Lost Boys, national tour of Disney’s Frozen)
Mathew Fedorek (national tours of Funny Girl and A Beautiful Noise)
Katie Gilhooley (Wilderness! and Packed off-Broadway)
Sam Moffatt
Madison Mosley (Beetlejuice)
Kathryn Paidoussis
Keyon Pickett (The Wiz national tour)
Emma Puscalau
Renée Salewski
Allie Weintraub
Meghan Renee Wombles

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Featuring

Cameron Krauss smiles softly, her straight, shoulder-length dark hair framing her face. She wears a red square-neck top and displays a floral tattoo on her left shoulder. A nose ring adds flair against the plain light blue background.

Stephanie Ainsworth

More
A young man with dark skin and short hair smiles gently. He is wearing a black shirt and is posed against a soft pink background, looking directly at the camera in this close-up portrait by Audrey Graves.

Nile Andah

More
Matthew Barge, a young man with wavy brown hair and a light beard, smiles at the camera while wearing a dark blue crew-neck shirt against a light-colored, paneled wall.

Matthew Barge

More

Bryanna Cuthill

Producer
More
Smiling Dominic Dorset with short curly hair and a trimmed beard, wearing a brown corduroy jacket over a green collared shirt. Neutral light gray background.

Dominic Dorset

More
Mathew Fedorek, a young man with curly light brown hair and blue eyes, looks at the camera. He wears a black leather jacket over a light shirt against a plain dark gray background, with even lighting highlighting his face.

Mathew Fedorek

More
Katie Gilhooley has a short, dark pixie haircut and a warm, slight smile as she looks directly at the camera. She has light skin, defined eyebrows, and wears a brown plaid shirt over a dark green top against a mottled, earth-toned background.

Katie Gilhooley

More
A close-up portrait of a smiling bald man with a full beard, wearing a grey crew-neck sweater. He has light eyes and is positioned against a solid, deep blue background.

Sam Moffatt

More
A woman with medium skin, curly dark hair, and brown eyes smiles softly. She wears a cream knit top and multiple earrings. The background is olive green. Her makeup is natural, with subtle blush and lipstick—captured in the signature, expressive portrait style of Christian Probst.

Madison Mosley

More
Kathryn Paidoussis is a smiling young woman with dark hair and brown eyes looking directly at the camera. She has a small stud in her nose, wears gold hoop earrings, and is set against a plain brown background.

Kathryn Paidoussis

More
A headshot of Keyon Pickett, a young Black man with short, dark curly hair and a neutral expression. He is wearing a dark olive green crew-neck sweater against a solid, light brown studio background.

Keyon Pickett

More
A headshot of Emma Puscalau with long, voluminous curly brown hair against a deep red background. She has blue-green eyes, a neutral expression, and is wearing a dark halter top and a small pearl earring.

Emma Puscalau

More
Renée Salewski smiles broadly at the camera, her shoulder-length auburn hair framing her face. She wears a white top against a solid, muted blue background.

Renée Salewski

Producer
More
Allie Weintraub, a young woman with long, loosely wavy blonde hair and blue eyes, smiles gently at the camera. She is wearing a white button-up shirt against a plain, light background, with soft natural lighting highlighting her features.

Allie Weintraub

Producer
More
A portrait of Meghan Renee Wombles, a young woman with shoulder-length brown hair and blue eyes, smiling softly at the camera. She wears a denim overall dress over a white top against a solid pink background, with a small nose piercing visible on her left nostril.

Meghan Renee Wombles

More
A young woman with straight brown hair wears a teal turtleneck sweater and large circular gold earrings. Abby Gorsuch smiles softly at the camera. The background is a blurred gray pattern.

Abby Gorsuch

Music Director
More

Pricing

  • $19.50 (includes $4.50 in fees) – $47 (includes $7 in fees)
  • VIP Seating: $52.50 (includes $7.50 in fees)
  • Premiums: $58 (includes $8 in fees)
  • Additional $6 If Purchased At Venue
  • Order Fees: 10% of ticket price, plus $3 facility fee
  • $25 Food & Beverage Minimum

Times(show / doors open)

Buy Tickets View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map

54 Below’s programs are made possible by the New York State Council on the Arts with the support of the Office of the Governor and the New York State Legislature.

254 W 54th St. Cellar, NYC 10019 [MAP]

Tickets & Info: (646) 476-3551

Send us a question
© 2026 54 Below Inc. All rights reserved. All artists, acts, dates, and show listings may be subject to change at any time.
Privacy Policy
The image features the logo of "54 Below," a renowned cabaret and dining club. The logo uses an elegant serif font with the number "54" prominently displayed and the word "BELOW" situated underneath. The text is gold on a dark brown background with a gold border surrounding the design.
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance (opens in a new tab)
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognizing you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.