Skip to main content


54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

Which love stories are allowed to be told? Show Me Eternity, a new musical about everlasting love and the erasure of queer identity tells a story hidden for over a century: the romance between Emily Dickinson and Sue Gilbert.

Show Me Eternity features music and lyrics by Sam Caps and book and lyrics by Annie Dillon. Dillon and Caps are an emerging writing duo with a passion for telling queer stories through the lens of history. Join us for an evening of bewitching poetry, ethereal folk/pop music, and an unforgettable story.

Directed by Daniella Caggiano (Fun Home at Plaza Community Chapel featuring Jenn Colella, Glass Town)

Mia Angelique [she/her] (Little Shop of Horrors at Short North Stage, Pride and Prejudice)
Katrien Van Riel [she/her] (Hank Williams: Lost HighwayMacGyver the Musical)
Tyler Dobies [he/him] (Songs for a New World at Village Theatre)
Ray Elizabeth Wilson [she/they] (Crucible, PA; Type Me Queer)
Anne Elizabeth Miele [she/they] (10×10, Clean Dishes)
Rachael Chau [she/they] (Les Misérables at bergenPAC, Thirteen/WNET’s Mission US)
Aliza Ciara [she/her] (Babes in Arms, Tré Ex Machina)
Chokwe [he/him] (Spring Awakening at Polluted Light Theatre Company, Dreamgirls)
Milo Longenecker [he/him] (Pride and Prejudice, Quiltbag)

Photo by Jody Christopherson

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Past Performances

  • Wed, Nov 9 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map