Skip to main content


54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

It’s nothing personal, just show business. Join us at Feinstein’s/54 Below as we present a concert of songs from the hilarious, new musical comedy What Do Critics Know?

In a strange turn of fate, three of the most powerful theater critics are forced to write a Broadway musical that must receive rave reviews. Will the critics succeed despite their overly critical natures? Find out if poetic justice will be served cold or in a warm review.

Returning to NY after an award-winning, sold-out run at the New York Musical Theatre Festival, this one night concert will feature tender ballads and rousing showstoppers presented by a terrific lineup of Broadway performers. Written by and for lovers of classic musical theater, this show will silence your inner critic and leave you humming!


Rachel De Benedet (Catch Me If You Can)
Matthew Gurren
Hunter Ryan Herdlicka (A Little Night Music)
Kristoffer Lowe (On The Twentieth Century)
Mary Mossberg (Kinky Boots)
Brian Charles Rooney (The Threepenny Opera)
Prescott Seymour (Bunnicula)
James Conrad Smith (The Hunchback of Notre Dame)
Sarah Stevens (Jekyll & Hyde)

The musical features music and lyrics by James Campodonico and book, music and lyrics by Matthew Gurren. The concert is directed by Kimothy Cruse with music direction by Eric Svejcar.

Past Performances

  • Tue, Jun 5 :7:00 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map