Skip to main content


54 Below

In 1985, triple-threat Dan Goggin introduced the world to a delightful group of nuns, The Little Sisters of Hoboken. The Sisters have traveled the world, and even appeared in more than eight sequels! Now, The Little Sisters of Hoboken will finally make their Feinstein’s/54 Below debut in Nunsense! The Sisters’ cook, Sister Julia, Child of God, has accidentally poisoned 52 of the other Sisters, and they are in dire need of funds for the burials. What better way to raise the funds than a variety show?

Join The Little Sisters of Hoboken for a very special night at New York’s hottest supper club.

Nunsense will return to New York for one night only with a starry cast. The evening is presented by the team behind the popular Second Act Series, Steven Carl McCasland and James Horan, who brought Onward Victoria, Charlie and Algernon, 70, Girls, 70, Nick & Nora, Shelter starring Jon Cryer, Henry, Sweet Henry, and Eating Raoul to Feinstein’s/54 Below. The evening features Musical Direction by Horan and Direction by McCasland.

Patti Mariano (The Music Man, Rags, The Full Monty) as Mother Superior Mary Regina
Bambi Jones (Nunsense Original TV Series) as Sister Mary Hubert
Tari Kelly
(Groundhog Day, Something Rotten, Anything Goes) as Sister Mary Amnesia
Carly Sakolove
(Newsical) as Sister Mary Robert
Erica Leigh Hansen
(Nunsense, Cats, Rocktopia, The Wild Party) as Sister Mary Leo

Also featuring former Nunsense cast members:
Shelby Anderson
Arianna Armon
Karen Asconi
Jenn Bedell
Kristen Gehling
Whitney Hickman
Nicole Sartor
Nikki Switzer

Past Performances

  • Mon, Mar 19 :7:00 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map