Skip to main content

Welcome

To
54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

Colorful squares display the words “OH” in teal, “EM” in pink, and “GEE” in purple. Below, red text reads “they sang this on Glee,” celebrating iconic Glee performances with

Oh Em Gee, They Sang This on Glee!

September 27, 2026

Broadway’s brightest stars celebrate “Glee” in an evening of your favorite “Glee” covers! This is for the people who always hear a song and say, “Oh Em Gee, They Sang This on Glee!” Get ready to hear hits like “Smooth Criminal,” “Rumor Has It/Someone Like You,” “Make You Feel My Love,” “Somewhere Only We Know,” and of course, “Rose’s Turn” (Kurt Hummel version)… plus so much more!

Featuring a cast of theater kids and Gleeks, this is a must-see event!

Produced by Natalie Pace.

Music direction by Cameron Krauss.

Co-directed by Nick Ammon and Natalie Pace.

Featuring:

Alexis Archer
Aaron Ballentine
Lucas Brown
Landry Champlin (“American Idol”)
Olivia Conti
Payton Daly
Kylah Frazier
Lizzy Marie Legregin (Disney’s Aladdin, Back To The Future)
Echo Deva Picone
Hayden Poe
Hayley Sutton
Christopher James Tamayo (Maybe Happy Ending)
Jenna Tiso
RJ Vandenbrouck
Sasha Winters

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Featuring

A young man with short dark hair, thick eyebrows, and light skin smiles softly. He wears a dark jacket over a white shirt. The blurred background has pink and beige tones, creating a warm, gentle atmosphere.

Nick Ammon

Co-Director
More
A young woman with long, wavy brown hair poses against a blue background in an Aaron Ballentine-inspired portrait. She has light eyes, clear fair skin, and natural makeup with subtle lip gloss. She wears small earrings and no visible clothing straps, giving the image a slightly formal, portrait feel.

Alexis Archer

More
A young man, Aaron Ballentine, with short, curly brown hair and blue eyes looks into the camera with a slight smile. He wears a light blue collared shirt over a white undershirt. The background is a smooth, gradient blue.

Aaron Ballentine

More
Matthew Angelaccio, a young man with light brown hair, smiles slightly at the camera. He wears a plain white T-shirt. The dark gray background enhances his features, and with his neatly styled hair, the image exudes a professional, portrait-like quality.

Lucas Brown

More
A young woman with straight, shoulder-length blonde hair poses against a light blue background. Inspired by Landon Zwick's minimalist style, she wears gold hoop earrings and natural makeup, her blue eyes and glossy lips exuding confidence as she faces the camera.

Landry Champlin

More
Olivia Conti, a young woman with long wavy brown hair, smiles at the camera. She has light skin, wears natural makeup, and is dressed in a light-colored, patterned top. The softly blurred background keeps the focus on her face.

Olivia Conti

More
A smiling young woman with long blonde hair wears a black

Payton Daly

More
Matthew Angelaccio, with long braided hair, is smiling slightly against a vibrant red background. Wearing a dark top, his expression is calm and confident. The lighting highlights Matthew's facial features and hair texture beautifully.

Kylah Frazier

More
A young person with short curly brown hair and light skin is smiling widely, showing teeth. They are wearing a black blazer over a dark top, against a plain dark background. The lighting highlights their face, creating a warm and joyful atmosphere.

Cameron Krauss

Music Director
More
A young woman with long, wavy dark hair smiles warmly at the camera. She is wearing a sleeveless orange top and small hoop earrings. Her makeup is natural, and the background is plain white, drawing focus to her cheerful expression.

Lizzy Marie Legregin

More
A young woman with long, wavy brown hair poses against a warm brown background. She is smiling softly, has light skin, and wears subtle makeup. She is dressed in a burgundy top and small gold hoop earrings, giving a natural and elegant appearance.

Natalie Pace

Producer/Co-Director
More
A young woman with long, curly auburn hair and light skin looks at the camera with a neutral expression. She has blue eyes, minimal makeup, and wears a delicate gold necklace by Jacob Phillips. The background is plain and light-colored.

Echo Deva Picone

More
A young man with curly, voluminous dark hair smiles gently while holding his hair up with both hands. Styled by Coral Rosario-Laboy, he wears a light blue button-up shirt and appears confident and relaxed against a neutral gray background.

Hayden Poe

More
Hayley Sutton, a young woman with long, wavy brown hair, smiles gently and tilts her head slightly. She wears a bright pink sleeveless top and a delicate necklace, standing against a plain white background with a warm glow and relaxed expression.

Hayley Sutton

More
Christopher James Tamayo, with short black hair and medium skin tone, looks directly at the camera. He is wearing a textured dark blue sweater against a soft beige background. The even lighting highlights his expressive eyes and relaxed expression beautifully.

Christopher James Tamayo

More
A woman with long, wavy brown hair and fair skin smiles slightly. She has blue-green eyes, natural makeup with pink lipstick, and wears gold earrings and a maroon top. The background is a plain, dark gray color.

Jenna Tiso

More
A young man with short, wavy brown hair smiles at the camera. RJ Vandenbrouck wears a beige textured shirt with the collar open and a silver chain necklace with an

RJ Vandenbrouck

More
A young woman with long blonde hair smiles softly in front of a dark green background. She wears a sleeveless dark brown top with a high neckline and small gold hoop earrings, styled by RJ Vandenbrouck. Her makeup is natural with light pink lipstick.

Sasha Winters

More

Pricing

  • $30.50 (includes $5.50 in fees) – $41.50 (includes $6.50 in fees)
  • VIP Seating: $47 (includes $7 in fees)
  • Premiums: $52.50 (includes $7.50 in fees)
  • Additional $6 If Purchased At Venue
  • Order Fees: 10% of ticket price, plus $3 facility fee
  • $25 Food & Beverage Minimum

Times(show / doors open)

Buy Tickets View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map

54 Below’s programs are made possible by the New York State Council on the Arts with the support of the Office of the Governor and the New York State Legislature.

254 W 54th St. Cellar, NYC 10019 [MAP]

Tickets & Info: (646) 476-3551

Send us a question
© 2026 54 Below Inc. All rights reserved. All artists, acts, dates, and show listings may be subject to change at any time.
Privacy Policy
The image features the logo of "54 Below," a renowned cabaret and dining club. The logo uses an elegant serif font with the number "54" prominently displayed and the word "BELOW" situated underneath. The text is gold on a dark brown background with a gold border surrounding the design.
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognizing you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.