Santino Fontana: You Asked For It
Dec 18 & 20, 2026
You pick the songs. He deals with the consequences.
After his third sex tape didn’t take off, Tony Award® winner Santino Fontana is back at the mic. This time, he’s letting the audience call the shots. On December 18 and 20, Santino returns to 54 Below with a show that hands control of the setlist to the people who buy tickets. Each ticket order can submit up to five song requests, and every song performed that night will come from those requests. Broadway? Jazz? Pop? Christmas carols? Holiday classics? An obscure song from a musical that closed in previews? Go ahead. Make his life difficult.
No two shows will be alike. There’s no predetermined setlist. And while not every request will make the cut, every song he sings will have been chosen by someone in that night’s audience. Will there be fancy guest singers? Maybe. Will it be an exhilarating evening of music-making or a spectacular public disaster? Also maybe. Either way, you can say you were responsible.
Buy a ticket. Request your songs. See what happens.
Ticket buyers will receive an email with a link to submit up to five requests. One request link per order.
Santino Fontana won the Tony®, Drama Desk, and Outer Critics Circle Awards for his performance in Tootsie, playing both a struggling actor and a considerably more successful actress. He is also known as the voice of Prince Hans in Disney’s Frozen and for his performances in “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend,” “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel,” and FX’s “Grotesquerie.” He recently completed filming the independent feature MAGIC TIME opposite Matthew Broderick, Cynthia Nixon, and Patti LuPone, and will appear in an upcoming episode of the CBS series “CUPERTINO.”
His Broadway credits include Cinderella (Tony® nomination), Hello, Dolly!, Act One, Brighton Beach Memoirs (Drama Desk Award), The Importance of Being Earnest, Billy Elliot, and Sunday in the Park with George. He also received Obie and Lucille Lortel Awards for Sons of the Prophet. A winner of the Lionel Hampton Jazz Festival, Fontana is an accomplished interpreter of the American Songbook and has performed with the New York Philharmonic, New York Pops, National Symphony Orchestra, and numerous other orchestras, as well as at Carnegie Hall, Lincoln Center, the Kennedy Center, and Birdland.
@santinofontana
Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.
Pricing
- $41.50 (includes $6.50 in fees) – $91 (includes $11 in fees)
- VIP Seating: $118.50 (includes $7 in fees)
- Premiums: $151.50 (includes $16.50 in fees) – $157 (includes $17 in fees)
- Additional $6 If Purchased At Venue
- Order Fees: 10% of ticket price, plus $3 facility fee
- $25 Food & Beverage Minimum