Skip to main content

Welcome

To
54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

Gold script and bold capitals read: “Sarah Goodman: Lesbian Thespian’s Broadway Diva Collection” against luxurious purple and black curtains, capturing the elegance and charisma of a true Broadway Diva in stylish cursive and striking block fonts.

Sarah Goodman: Lesbian Thespian’s Broadway Diva Collection, feat. Jackie Burns & more!

April 8, 2026

This performance will also be livestreamed. For tickets and more information, click here.

“Charming, witty, personable,- all the while singing the songs that a well-trained musical theater performer could, should, and would sing for their supper.”

“Deep and heartfelt.”

-Stephen Mosher, BroadwayWorld 

Sarah Goodman has appeared on the 54 Below stage in her solo show Lesbian Thespian, Macon… His Own Way: The Comeback, GOOD SHOW!, her duo sibling cabaret show, 54 Does 54, and Sondheim Unplugged.

Sarah Goodman returns to 54 Below in the latest edition of Lesbian Thespian: Lesbian Thespian’s Broadway Diva Collection! Sarah shares her stories of being a showbiz kid who lives in NYC but is “not yet a New Yorker.” Living her theatre kid dreams, Sarah has met and befriended many of her favorite Broadway Divas and those very Divas are joining Sarah to sing some Broadway bangers. Hear music from Stephen Sondheim, Kander and Ebb, musical theatre medleys, and more!

Directed by Dana Kelly Craig, with music direction by Kerianne Brennan.

Featuring Broadway Divas:

Jackie Burns (If/Then, Hair, Wicked)
Natalie Joy Johnson (Lempicka, Kinky Boots, Legally Blonde)
Salisha Thomas (Once Upon A One More Time, Beautiful: The Carole King Musical), and more stars to be announced!

Also joined by Katherine Winter.

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Featuring

Sarah Goodman, a woman with long, dark, curly hair, smiles at the camera. She wears red lipstick, a black top, and a colorful floral blazer against a solid olive green background that highlights her vibrant expression.

Sarah Goodman

More
Dana Kelly Craig, a woman with long, wavy auburn hair and fair skin, looks thoughtfully to the side. She has blue eyes, subtle makeup, and wears a black top with a dark necklace. The dark background highlights her features and expression.

Dana Kelly Craig

Director
More
Kerrianne Brennan, a young woman with curly blonde hair, smiles warmly at the camera. She is wearing a black top and black blazer. The background is slightly blurred, with framed photos and a white wall visible behind her.

Kerianne Brennan

Music Director
More
Jackie Burns, with wavy dark hair and light eyes, tilts her head, smiling softly. She wears a blue denim button-up shirt with white snaps and silver hoop earrings. Her hand touches her hair against a plain soft gray background.

Jackie Burns

More
A person with short, platinum blonde hair and light skin poses against a plain dark background. Wearing a mauve lace halter top, they reveal a floral tattoo on their left shoulder—capturing Natalie Joy Johnson's calm, confident gaze directly at the camera.

Natalie Joy Johnson

More
Salisha Thomas, with her curly hair, gold hoop earrings, and bright red top, smiles broadly at the camera against a soft blue background. Her relaxed posture and radiant expression exude confidence, joy, and enthusiasm.

Salisha Thomas

More
Katherine Winter, with short, wavy blonde hair and light skin, smiles gently against a bright red background. She wears bold red lipstick, hoop earrings, and a red halter strap, with subtle makeup and bare shoulders.

Katherine Winter

More

Sarah Goodman sings "Everybody Says Don't" from Anyone Can Whistle at 54 Below!

54 Below

Past Performances

  • Wed, Apr 8 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map