Skip to main content


54 Below

Stranger Sings! The Parody Musical

Take a trip back to Hawkins, Indiana: 1983 —when times were simpler, hair was bigger, and unsupervised children were getting snatched by inter-dimensional creatures.

Stranger Sings! is a parody musical that lovingly riffs on the first two seasons of that one 80’s-themed Netflix show and all its campy nostalgic glory. Join Mike, Eleven, Lucas, Dustin, and the whole Hawkins gang for a night of adventure, thrills, indulgent pop culture references, pubescent angst, heavy synth, poor parenting, convoluted love triangles, cheap effects, singing monsters, and maybe, just maybe, justice for everyone’s favorite frumpy ginger, Barb Holland. Featuring an exciting cast of NYC Theatre and Feinstein’s/54 Below favorites, prepare to go Upside Down with Stranger Sings! The Parody Musical! 


Christina Bianco (Forbidden Broadway) as Joyce
James Bock (Castle On a CloudMillion Dollar Quartet) as Hopper
Dean Cestari
(Here and Now, Mamma Mia at ACT) as Will
Jonathan Hogue (FRIENDS: I Was There for You) as Steve
Patrick Howard (NYTF, The Timekeeper) as Dustin
Blair Medina (Heist! The Musical) as Eleven
Savannah-Lee Mumford (PITS!Into the Woods) as Barb
Michael Pigliavento (FRIENDS: I Was There for You) as Demagorgon
Robert Lee Poole III as Lucas
Emily Kay Shrader
(Sister Act National Tour) as Nancy
Nathan David Smith (Thousand Faced Theatre, METRO) as Jonathan
Jackson Walker (Hello, Dolly! at Lyric Theatre) as Mike

Written by: Jonathan Hogue
Directed by: Nick Flatto
Orchestrations and Music Direction by: Michael Kaish
Production Designer: Allison Hartfield
Marketing Manager: Adyson Johnson
Executive Producers: Dena Hardee, Michael Pigliavento, Allison Hartfield 

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Past Performances

  • Thu, Jan 10 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map