Skip to main content


54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

The running time of this performance is 2 hours

A New York City Twisted Holiday Tradition celebrates its Thirteenth Year of putting the “extra” in “extravaganza!”

They say that good things come to those who wait, and Mr. Iconis is pleased to announce that after three bah humbug years of pandemic pause, Christmas is coming like never before. Joe and his merry band of musical theater punks are proud to reignite their legendary holiday tradition and bring their insane celebration of all things red and green back to 54 Below.

Written by Joe Iconis, directed by John Simpkins, and produced by Jennifer Ashley Tepper, this wild yuletide explosion is part rock concert, part theater piece, and part theme park attraction come to life. Featuring brand new holiday songs, old favorites, a huge cast of musical theater all-stars, tiny elves, enormous reindeer, an inebriated Mr. and Mrs. Claus, and more whiskey-fueled shenanigans than you can shake a candy cane at, it promises to be the hap-hap-happiest holiday hoedown ever seen on stage.

The show will feature special guest star Annie Golden, as well as the following family members:


Sara Al-Bazali
Philippe Arroyo
(11pm shows only)
Nick Blaemire (Sat shows only)
Liz Lark Brown
Chad Burris
(11pm shows only)
Gerard Canonico (No Fri at 7pm)
Harrison Chad
Bill Coyne
Laura Dadap
Giovanny Diaz de Leon

Katrina Rose Dideriksen (7pm shows only)
Rick Edinger
John El-Jor
Vince Fazzolari
Andrew Barth Feldman
Kalonjee Gallimore (no Fri and Sat at 7pm)
Omar Garibay
Drew Gehling
(Fri and Sun shows only)
Danielle Gimbal
Morgan Siobhan Green
Van Hughes
(Sat shows only)
Ian Kagey
Lorinda Lisitza
Lauren Marcus
Julia Mattison (Fri and Sun shows only)
Kelly McIntyre
Jeremy Morse (7pm shows only)
Kevin Michael Murphy
Allison Philips

Josh Plotner
Sam Primack

Will Roland
Charlie Rosen
(Sun at 7pm only)
Mike Rosengarten
Jackie Sanders
MiMi Scardulla
Brooke Shapiro
Helen J Shen
A.J. Shively
Noah Silverman

Lena Skeele
Murphy Taylor Smith
Philip Jackson Smith
Brent Stranathan
Jax Terry
Alysha Umphress
(Sun at 7pm only)
Vinnie Urdea
Tatiana Wechsler
Jared Weiss
Jason SweetTooth Williams
Alyssa Wray
(Fri and Sat at 11 only)
and more stars to be announced!

E Sara Barnes stage manages, Christine O’Grady and Jennifer Werner choreograph, and costumes are by Brendan McCann. Max Friedman is assistant director, Alexa Spiegel is associate producer, and Bailey Ford, Carly Heitner, Molly Heller, and Faith King are PAs.

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Past Performances

  • Fri, Dec 8 :7:00 pm
  • Fri, Dec 8 :11:00 pm
  • Sat, Dec 9 :7:00 pm
  • Sat, Dec 9 :11:00 pm
  • Sun, Dec 10 :7:00 pm
  • Sun, Dec 10 :11:00 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map