Skip to main content


54 Below

Back by popular demand after a sold-out show last year, Tyler Conroy’s Very Broadway Bae Christmas returns to Feinstein’s/54 Below. This year’s show will have a new spin featuring your favorite holiday songs plus selections from the musical Rent; a little Rentmas mome if you will. Kick off the Christmas season with a night of singing along to classics sung by some of Broadway’s brightest stars. Dawn your favorite ugly sweater, break out the jingle bells, and join Tyler for a night that’ll leave you filled with Christmas cheer.

Tyler Conroy is a YouTuber/Singer-Songwriter known for his web series “Tyvid Tuesday” which has been viewed over 20 million times and featured by Playbill, Huffington Post, Entertainment Weekly, and BroadwayWorld. You may have also seen him singing his order at Taco Bell Drive-Thrus in his “Aca-Taco Bell” videos. He’s the author of Simon & Schuster’s Taylor Swift biography “This Is Our Song” & you can sometimes find him hosting red carpet events with His debut album “Tyler Conroy LIVE at Rockwood Music Hall” featuring 9 original songs is releasing November 13th. This is Tyler’s 4th installment of his “Broadway Bae” series at Feinstein’s/54 Below & he is very grateful they keep inviting him back to do what he loves more than anything.


Zach Adkins (Anastasia)
Melanie Brook (Bubble Boy54 Sings Ariana Grande)
Adrian Grace Bumpas
(Broadway Baes)
Joey Contreras
Katy Geraghty (Groundhog Day)
Peter LaPrade (Lightning Thief, This Ain’t No Disco)
Daniel Mertzlufft (54 Sings Jonas Brothers, Music Director)
Jiana Odland (Broadway Baes)
Luca Padovan (Newsies)
Jelani Remy (Smokey Joe’s Cafe, The Lion King)
Colton Ryan (Dear Evan Hansen, Girl From The North Country)

More “Baes” To Be Announced Soon!


T.J. Conroy (Guitar/Vocals/Tyler’s Dad)
A.J. Krawczyk (Percussion)

Past Performances

  • Sat, Dec 1 :11:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map