Skip to main content


54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

What if Aladdin and Jasmine sang “Carry You Home” as a representation of their newfound love? What if Karen Smith sings “Naughty” while telling the audience about what it’s really like to be a high schooler in modern times? Join us for an exciting evening of What Ifs as your favorite characters sing musical theater songs that normally have no relation to them, all while interacting with characters that they usually never get the chance to speak to. Come see familiar and new faces, from Broadway and beyond, sing unexpected combinations of the most beloved musicals in our fifth installment of this series, while you ponder the question, What If?

Produced and music directed by Jorden Amir.


Angelina Amato (Elsa)
Brayden Bambino (Tommy Walker)
Natalie Kaye Clater (Jasmine)
Helora Danna
Brielle Diaz Withers (Wednesday Addams)
Kaileigh Fiorillo
(Elle Woods)
Isabela Garcia (Sue Snell)
Sarah Isola (Karen Smith)
Molly Jobe (Jenna)
Halle Just (Audrey)
Mikey Mousaw (Buddy the Elf)
Katie Nieto (Jovie)
Juliette Ojeda (Young Allie)
Moana Poyer (Becky)
Chloe Pugh
(Gretchen Wieners)
Allie Trimm (Glinda)
Ayden Weinstein (Tony)
David Wright (Aladdin)

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.


  • $40 (includes $5 in fees) – $51 (includes $6 in fees)
  • VIP Seating: $62 (includes $7 in fees)
  • Premiums: $84 (includes $9 in fees)
  • Prices shown are only valid for online purchases. Additional $6 in fees for all seating sections if purchased at the box office.
  • $25 Food & Beverage Minimum

Times(show / doors open)

Buy Tickets View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map