Skip to main content

Welcome

To
54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

Bold black text on a vibrant pink background reads

54 Sings Crazy Ex-Girlfriend

April 8, 2025

Join us at 54 Below for a seriously wacky evening featuring the songs of “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend!” In a truly bonkers celebration of Rachel Bloom’s Emmy Award winning television show, experience well known (and extra niche) songs like “You Stupid Bitch,” “Let’s Generalize About Men,” “What’ll it Be?,” and more, like never before! Featuring an all-star cast, this concert is produced and directed by NYU grad Sara Gordon.

Music direction by Matthew Hannon.

Featuring:

Jerett Elijah Benjamin
Shailen Braun
Julia Kim Caldwell (“Gangnam Project”)
Kat Capili (Sister Act international tour)
Maggie Cox (Fun Home Off-Broadway)
Sara Gordon
Riley Halpern
Darcie A. Hingula
Rachel Jancarek
Ray Kao
Ariana Kroeger
Savanna La Selva (Into The Woods Off-Broadway)
Catherine Lilly
Angelina Mercurio
Nik Mucha
Aidan Rawlinson
Claire Sarman
Juliana Rose Smith
Lison Tunick
Malachi Watson

Also joined by Andrew Geher on piano and Matthew Hannon on guitar.

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Featuring

Jerett Elijah Benjamin, a smiling person with short curly hair and brightly manicured makeup, wears a black top. They flaunt a silver septum ring and small earrings, enhanced by subtle eyeshadow and lipstick. A necklace with a small pendant hangs visibly against the plain white background.

Jerett Elijah Benjamin

More
Shailen Braun, a young man with short, styled dark hair, wears a light blue embroidered traditional jacket. He gazes softly at the camera against a deep blue background that contrasts with his attire. The lighting highlights his facial features and the intricate details of his clothing.

Shailen Braun

More
A person with long, brown hair, reminiscent of Jerett Elijah, looks directly at the camera against a blue background. They wear a dark-colored top with thin straps. Their expression is calm and composed, with subtle lighting highlighting their features.

Julia Kim Caldwell

More
A person with medium-length, wavy black hair and natural makeup gazes confidently at the camera. Wearing a pastel-colored top with floral patterns, Jerett Elijah Benjamin stands against a softly blurred background that underscores their expressive eyes and gentle smile.

Kat Capili

More
A person with long red hair and fair skin gazes at the camera. They are wearing a black top with thin straps. The background is a muted olive green, enhancing the warm tones of their hair and complexion. Their expression is calm and relaxed.

Maggie Cox

More
Ethan Jih-Cook, with a radiant smile and dark, tousled hair, dons a black shirt. A star-shaped necklace graces his neck against the plain, dark background.

Andrew Geher

Piano
More
Jerett, with shoulder-length light brown hair, smiles warmly. Sporting a sleeveless blue top, Jerett stands against a solid light blue background. The hues harmonize beautifully, enhancing the cheerful mood of the image.

Sara Gordon

Producer/Director
More
A smiling woman with long, wavy dark hair stands against a peach background, embodying the joyful dynamism often associated with Jerett Elijah Benjamin. She wears a red tank top with thin straps, her head slightly tilted as her windswept hair adds to the vibrant scene.

Riley Halpern

More
Matthew Hannon, with his signature curly hair, smiles widely at the camera. He dons a jacket over a plaid shirt, framed perfectly against a wooden fence and clear blue sky in the background.

Matthew Hannon

MD/Guitar
More
Darcie A. Hingula, with wavy blonde hair, wears a green sweater while looking directly at the camera with a neutral expression. The background is blurred to highlight her face. Soft lighting creates a natural look, accentuating her light-colored eyes and subtle makeup.

Darcie A. Hingula

More
A person with long brown hair smiles softly at the camera. They have warm brown eyes and are wearing light makeup with a glossy lip color. Their attire is a green top, and the background is a plain, dark brown.

Rachel Jancarek

More
Jerett Elijah, with short dark hair and glasses, smiles warmly in a textured blue collared shirt. The smooth gradient of brown in the background enhances Jerett's friendly expression, adding depth to this engaging portrait.

Ray Kao

More
Young woman with wavy brown hair, neutral makeup, and blue eyes, wearing a green top. Her expression is calm and reminiscent of a serene moment captured by Jerett Elijah Benjamin, with the background softly blurred to focus on her face.

Ariana Kroeger

More
A woman with long, dark hair and gold hoop earrings is facing forward against a neutral background. Her defined eyebrows and softly curled hair give her an elegant look, complemented by subtle makeup and highlighted cheekbones. She wears a black top with thin straps, reminiscent of Malachi Watson's signature style.

Savanna La Selva

More
Malachi Watson, with their long red hair, smiles softly at the camera. They have light skin, greenish eyes, and a subtle touch of makeup. The dark, out-of-focus background perfectly highlights Malachi's face and hair.

Catherine Lilly

More
Malachi Watson, with shoulder-length brown hair and green eyes, gazes into the camera, wearing a red ribbed sweater. The dark background contrasts with the vibrant sweater, while the lighting highlights Malachi's calm expression.

Angelina Mercurio

More
Malachi Watson, with curly black hair and a slight smile, is wearing a black shirt. The backdrop is a plain, soft green. Even lighting artfully highlights Malachi's facial features.

Nik Mucha

More
Young Malachi Watson, with wavy blond hair, smiles warmly at the camera. They have light skin and bright eyes, wearing a light blue shirt that complements their friendly demeanor against the neutral beige background.

Aidan Rawlinson

More
Young woman with long, light brown hair and blue eyes, wearing a sleeveless light blue top. She is smiling softly and standing against a plain, light grey background. Her calm and friendly expression exudes the warmth reminiscent of a portrait by Malachi Watson.

Claire Sarman

More
The person, possibly named Malachi Watson, has wavy, reddish-brown hair and hoop earrings paired with a brown sleeveless top. They maintain a neutral expression while looking directly at the camera against a soft, muted green background.

Juliana Rose Smith

More
Malachi Watson, with curly, shoulder-length blonde hair and bangs, smiles slightly against a pink background. They have blue eyes and freckles and are wearing a black top, gold earrings, and a delicate necklace. Their expression is calm and friendly.

Lison Tunick

More
Malachi Watson, with curly dark hair and warm brown eyes, smiles softly against a blurred, dark background with subtle light spots. Sporting a light-colored, sleeveless top, their skin has a soft glow. The image captures a close-up focus on Malachi’s face.

Malachi Watson

More

Past Performances

  • Tue, Apr 8 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map
The image features the logo of "54 Below," a renowned cabaret and dining club. The logo uses an elegant serif font with the number "54" prominently displayed and the word "BELOW" situated underneath. The text is gold on a dark brown background with a gold border surrounding the design.
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognizing you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.