Skip to main content


54 Below

Fiorello!,. Cabaret, Dancin’, Anastasia. 

Those four musicals, plus many others, all made their Broadway debut on West 44th Street at the historic Broadhurst Theatre. Celebrating its 100th birthday this year, the Broadhurst is going to get a fabulous centennial celebration at Feinstein’s/54 Below.

Join us for an evening of songs and stories, performed by the legends themselves who were lucky enough to grace the Broadhurst stage!

The Untold Stories of Broadway’s Jennifer Ashley Tepper and Behind the Curtain’s Robert W Schneider will be on hand to share trivia and anecdotes about the theatre that has been home to such legends as Daniel Radcliffe, Nathan Lane, Elaine Stritch, Stephen Sondheim, and Neil Simon. Expect some of the Broadhurst’s favorite artists to make an appearance and wish this magical theater a happy 100th birthday!

At the 7pm performance
Jerry Adler (Oh What a Lovely War)
Eli Bolin (FoundVolley Girls)
Jim Brochu (Zero Hour)
Carole Demas (Grease)
Wayne Cilento (Dancin’)
Josh Franklin (Grease)
Marcy Harriell (Lennon)
Ilene Kristen (Grease)
Sarah Charles Lewis (Tuck Everlasting)
Howard McGillin (Kiss of the Spiderwoman)
John Miller (Mozart in the Jungle)
Christiane Noll (Ragtime)
Alice Ripley (American Psycho, Next To Normal)
Don Scardino (Godspell, Lennon)
Rebecca Spigelman (Hairspray)
Trivia Contest Video with Tony Award winner Jason Alexander (Seinfeld, Broadway Bound)

At the 9:30pm performance
Walter Bobbie (Grease) – Video Appearance
Eli Bolin (FoundVolley Girls)
Jim Brochu (Zero Hour)
Nathan Gardner (Big Fish)
Anita Gillette (Cabaret, Kelly)
Brian Michael Henry (Million Dollar Quartet)
Judy Kaye (Mamma Mia!)
Rob Maitner (Urinetown)
Paris Alexander Nesbitt (The Book of Mormon)
Lewis Stadlen (The Front Page, The Odd Couple)
Jodi Stevens (Urban Cowboy)
Representing Rachael Lily Rosenbloom and Don’t You Ever Forget It…
Kathryn Allison (Aladdin), Charlie Franklin (The Secret Garden), Anastacia McCleskey (Waitress), Bonnie Milligan (Kinky Boots), Kevin Michael Murphy (The Book of Mormon), Jason Veasey (The Lion King), and Natalie Walker (Puffs the Play).
Trivia Contest Video with Tony Award winner Jason Alexander (Seinfeld, Broadway Bound)

The evening will also feature an original song about the Broadhurst wth music and lyrics by Eli Bolin & Mike Pettry.

Hosted by Robert W. Schneider & Jennifer Ashley Tepper

Past Performances

  • Wed, Aug 16 :7:00 pm
  • Wed, Aug 16 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map