Skip to main content


54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

2016: Nerds

1976: The Baker’s Wife

1965: Pleasures and Palaces… 

Those three titles alone can stir the hearts of musical theatre fans who ask, “What could’ve been had these shows debuted on Broadway?”

Broadway Bound: The Musicals That Never Came to Broadway offers a behind the scenes look at the musicals that were supposed to come to Broadway but never did…told by the actors, writers, and directors who were there! 

From producers with no money, to actors who wouldn’t go on, to shows that were way ahead of their time, Broadway Bound will introduce New York audiences to the shows that were supposed to find a home on the Great White Way, all sung by an all star Broadway cast.

The concert will be co-hosted by author of The Untold Stories of Broadway, Jennifer Ashley Tepper, and host of the podcast, Behind The Curtain: Broadway’s Living Legends, Robert W. Schneider.

Featuring Broadway Stars:

From How Do You Do, I Love YouLoni Ackerman
From NerdsBryan Fenkart 
From All About Us… Tony Award winner Cady Huffman
Representing Prettybelle… Olivier Award winner Lesli Margherita
Representing RebeccaJill Paice
Representing SoftlyShelly Burch
Representing Mata Hari… Tony Award Winner Martin Charnin
Representing The Rhythm ClubNick Cartell (Jesus Christ Superstar)
Representing The Rhythm Club… AJ Shively (Bright Star
Representing The Rhythm Club… Danielle Gimbal (The Joe Iconis Christmas Spectacular)
Representing Harold & MaudeRita Gardner (7pm performance only)
Representing BabeRebecca Spigelman (Hairspray(7pm performance only)
Representing Arthur: The Musical… Kevin David Thomas (A Little Night Music(7pm performance only)
Representing Captain America… Jim Walton (Merrily We Roll Along(7pm performance only)
Representing Pleasures and PalacesPaige Davis (TV’s Trading Spaces)  (9:30pm performance only)
Representing The Baker’s WifeRyan Vona (Paramour(9:30pm performance only)
Representing Captain America… Robert Cuccioli (Jekyll and Hyde(9:30pm performance only)  

Produced & Directed by Robert W. Schneider

Past Performances

  • Tue, Mar 21 :7:00 pm
  • Tue, Mar 21 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map