Skip to main content


54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

Need a little Christmas in July? See the tale of Peter Pan gayer than you’ve ever seen it before! Join Peter and Drag Queen Gina Tonic as they burst out of the nursery and discover Neverland on acid with a foul mouthed Tink, pirates of the subway, and that big old sexy crocodile! Chock full of pop parodies and musical theatre classics, slapstick calamities and political satire abound like an over-stuffed package, full of surprises (wrapped up in a rainbow-colored bow).

Bold and bawdy, the pantomime, or panto, has been a tradition in Great Britain since 1717 and is usually performed throughout the holiday season. With its roots in commedia dell’arte, the genre takes classic fairy tales and imbues them with a broad and comedic twist. While pantos are traditionally considered family shows, Peter Pan-Sexual is a decidedly adult take on this very British entertainment. TL;DR- If you enjoyed Titanique, you’ll also get a kick out of this show!


Lily Ali-Oshatz (The Civility of Albert Cashier)
Robert K. Benson
Jonathan Nathaniel Dingle-El
(“The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel”)
Matt Mastromatteo
(The Refugee)
Rachel McPhee
(“Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt, Dead Shot Mary)
Regan Sims
(Shakespeare’s Globe, London)
Gabriel Spector
(Voices of Gotham)
Gina Tonic
(In The Know’s Behind The Drag series, “Katy Keene”)
Diego Velázquez
Elizabeth Wright (“Boardwalk Empire”)

Written by Robert K. Benson. The original December 2022 production was directed by David Charles. The Remount Direction and costumes are by Madeline Wall (“Russian Doll”), with stage management by Sarah Jones (An Evening with L Morgan Lee). Original music by Lily Ali-Oshatz and Gabriel Spector.

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Past Performances

  • Thu, Jul 13 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map