Skip to main content

Welcome

To
54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

A bubbling black cauldron sits amid crystals, potions, and an open spell book, emitting purple smoke.

Rotten to the 54: A Night of Spooks, Songs, and Spells

October 26, 2025

Calling all wicked queens, mischievous sidekicks, and descendants of evil — Rotten to the 54 is a brand-new Halloween cabaret full of magic, mayhem, and musical mischief.

Featuring songs from your favorite animated classics and movie musicals — including spooky hits from a certain coven of 1693 witches, enchanted high schools, and the darker side of the fairytale universe — this concert is packed with nostalgia, iconic bops, and just a dash of poison apple flair.

Performed by a cast of NYC’s fiercest vocalists, this night of spooks, songs, and spells is a celebration of the villains we love, the rebels we rooted for, and the characters who made being bad look so good.

Costumes encouraged. Magic guaranteed.

Produced by Luke Gilmore and Ginger Snap Theatrics.

Directed by Aly Marie Mazzie.

Music direction by Aidan S. Wells.

Featuring:

The Randy Andys
Andie Angel (Friends! The Musical Parody off-Broadway)
Maggie Bera
Shailen Patel Braun
Blacc Cherry
Jen Chia
Wes D’Alelio
Darcie A. Hingula
Alyssa Jaffe
Nicholas Kraft (DRAG: The Musical Off-Broadway)
Erich W. Schleck (Jesus Christ Superstar national tour, Blippi the Musical national tour)
Duncan B. Smith
Diana Taylor
Joseph Thor
Paul Tuaty
Kamiah Vickers
Chloë Wendler

Also joined by Kyle Roemer on the drums and Joseph Thor on the bass.

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Featuring

Three women in sparkly purple dresses sing into microphones on stage. They smile brightly under colorful lights, with musical instruments behind them. In the center, Alyssa Jaffe gestures with her hand while the others sing and pose beside her.

The Randy Andys

More
A young woman with long, wavy red hair and bangs poses in front of a dark blue background. She wears a light-colored top, small hoop earrings, and a delicate necklace with a star-shaped pendant. Her expression is neutral and her makeup is natural.

Andie Angel

More
Alyssa Jaffe, with long, blonde, tight curly hair, poses confidently against a dark background. She has light skin and blue eyes, wearing a sleeveless black top and denim jacket draped over her shoulder, smiling softly with a relaxed expression.

Maggie Bera

More
Shailen Braun, a young man with short, styled dark hair, wears a light blue embroidered traditional jacket. He gazes softly at the camera against a deep blue background that contrasts with his attire. The lighting highlights his facial features and the intricate details of his clothing.

Shailen Patel Braun

More
Alyssa Jaffe, with long, wavy silver hair and dramatic makeup, wears a sparkling sequined top. Pearl earrings accent the look as she poses confidently against a soft blue background, her hair wind-swept and expression self-assured.

Blacc Cherry

More
A young woman with wavy, shoulder-length black hair smiles warmly against a dark blue background. She wears gold hoop earrings, a burgundy top, a thin gold necklace, and a black leather jacket. Her makeup is natural, highlighting her dimples.

Jen Chia

More
A young person with short dark hair, clear skin, and a faint mustache smiles gently at the camera. Wes D'Alelio wears a dark green, ribbed, high-neck sweater and is posed in front of a plain gray background.

Wes D'Alelio

More
A young man with fair skin and short red hair, Luke Gilmore, smiles softly at the camera. He is wearing a green shirt with white vertical stripes. The background is softly blurred, keeping the focus on his face and upper body.

Luke Gilmore

Producer
More
Darcie A. Hingula, with wavy blonde hair, wears a green sweater while looking directly at the camera with a neutral expression. The background is blurred to highlight her face. Soft lighting creates a natural look, accentuating her light-colored eyes and subtle makeup.

Darcie A. Hingula

More
Alyssa Jaffe, a young woman with long, brown, wavy hair styled back, smiles softly at the camera in a sleeveless white top. She has clear skin, natural makeup with defined eyelashes, and is posed against a soft teal background.

Alyssa Jaffe

More
A young man with short, dark hair and fair skin looks directly at the camera with a slight smile. He wears a black shirt. The background is softly blurred in grey tones, putting focus on his face.

Nicholas J. Kraft

More
Diana Taylor, a woman with long, dark curly hair, poses against a plain gray background. She has light skin, brown eyes, neatly shaped eyebrows, natural makeup with pink lipstick, a small star tattoo near her collarbone, and a thin chain necklace.

Aly Marie Mazzie

Director
More
A young man with fair skin and short red hair smiles at the camera. He is wearing a patterned collared shirt under a dark sweater. The background is plain and light gray, giving the image a professional, studio-like feel.

Kyle Roemer

Drums
More
A person with fair skin and shoulder-length wavy blonde hair is looking confidently at the camera. They have bold eye makeup and wear a sleeveless black top. The background is a solid deep red color.

Erich W. Schleck

More
A young man with short, dark curly hair and fair skin looks at the camera, smiling slightly. He wears a brown raglan-style shirt with dark sleeves, posing against a solid, dark teal background for Diana Taylor's portrait series.

Duncan B. Smith

More
A glamorous person with voluminous, styled brown hair poses against a dark, silky backdrop. Channeling Diana Taylor, they wear dramatic makeup, dark lipstick, a jeweled ring atop a black glove, and a white fur stole—pure vintage Hollywood elegance.

Diana Taylor

More
A young man with short dark hair and pale skin tilts his head slightly and looks confidently at the camera. He wears a dark brown textured shirt. The background is a solid dark green, in the distinctive style of Lauren Torey. Even lighting highlights his features.

Joseph Thor

Bass
More
A young person with short, wavy brown hair and fair skin smiles gently at the camera. They wear a dark green henley shirt and a small hoop earring in one ear. The background is a solid warm brown color.

Paul Tuaty

More
Vivica Powell, a young woman with dark braided hair and glasses, smiles softly in a beige turtleneck. Her smooth skin and dark eyes stand out against the plain olive green background in this well-lit, professional portrait.

Kamiah Vickers

More
Aidan S. Wells, a young man with brown hair, glasses, and a beard, looks thoughtfully at the camera. He wears a green jacket over a beige shirt and holds a pen to his chin against a plain gray background with soft, even lighting on his face.

Aidan S. Wells

Music Director
More

Chloë Wendler

More

Past Performances

  • Sun, Oct 26 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map
The image features the logo of "54 Below," a renowned cabaret and dining club. The logo uses an elegant serif font with the number "54" prominently displayed and the word "BELOW" situated underneath. The text is gold on a dark brown background with a gold border surrounding the design.
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognizing you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.