Skip to main content


54 Below Presents Unexpected Songs will be an evening of the perfect blending between pop songs, musical theatre, and pure silliness as Broadway stars insert an unexpected song into their favorite musical. Imagine if Perchik sang Magic!’s “Rude” when Tevye tried to forbid his engagement to Hodel in Fiddler on the Roof or if Ogie sang Bruno Mars’ “Marry You” to Dawn in Waitress instead of “I Love You Like A Table”! Each performer will have a brief interview about their favorite musical, act out their Unexpected Song’s lead-in scene, and then sing their hearts out. Enjoy some laughter and fun with your favorite Broadway performers in this unique one-night-only event. Presents Unexpected Songs is produced by Fiddler on the Roof’s Michael Bernardi and’s editor-in-chief Samantha Stephens. Proceeds will benefit Muddy Paws Rescue.

Alex Boniello
Max Chernin

Caitlin Donohue
Lauren Elder
Megan Kane
Kate Loprest
Patti Murin
Tess Primack
Andrew Rannells

Ben Rappaport
Noah Weisberg

Aaron Young

And more to be announced!

Past Performances

  • Mon, Sep 5 :7:00 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map