Skip to main content


54 Below

In May, 1965, Joe Allen opened the restaurant that bears his name. That same year, the cast of the ill-fated show Kelly gave Joe a poster of their show. It ran one performance, and they thought it should hang, well, somewhere. Since then, it’s become a Broadway tradition for those unlucky flops to adorn the restaurant’s walls.

Directed and produced by Nick Flatto, The Ones That Got Away is a Valentine’s Day tribute to those forgotten flops as we remember the lost love songs of Broadway’s past. Featuring the incomparable current staff at Joe Allen Restaurant, The Ones That Got Away will take you back to a time more simple and full of love. Join us at Feinstein’s/54 Below as we celebrate the beauty of hope and unfulfilled dreams.


KC Comeaux (One Arm at The New Group)
Nicole Fernandez-Coffaro (Lady in the Dark at New York City Center, Evita at Actors’ Playhouse)
Michael Ray Fisher (Rocktopia, Elf National Tour)
Nick Flatto (A Christmas Story National Tour, Funny Thing Happened at Shakespeare Theatre Company)
Colin Lee (Beauty and the Beast National Tour, Guys and Dolls National Tour)
Megan McGarvey (Cabaret at Sharon Playhouse, CBS’s “Bull”)
Chris Persichetti (Hair, Rock of Ages at Forestburgh Playhouse, Memphis at Gateway)
Jonathan Wiener (Spamalot at Orlando Shakespeare Theatre; HBO’s “The Plot Against America”)
Will Wilkinson (Seussical the Musical with The Straw Hat Players)

Music Direction by Garrett Taylor.

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Past Performances

  • Mon, Feb 3 :7:00 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map