Skip to main content


54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

What if Orpheus and Eurydice sang “Come What May” to prove their love lasts forever? What if Anastasia sang “I’m Not That Girl” while she’s distressed because of her unknown identity? Join us for an exciting evening of What If‘s as we give your favorite musical theater songs to characters that normally have no relation to them. Come see familiar and new faces, from Broadway and beyond, sing unexpected combinations of the most beloved musicals in our fourth installment of this series, while you ponder the question, What If?

Produced and music directed by Jorden Amir.


Catalina Almeida (Fantine)
Angelina Amato
(Regina George)
Zack Bliss
(Seymour Krelborn)
Erin Rose Doyle
(Jenna Hunterson)
Gabe Escobar (Orpheus)
Isabela Garcia
Haley Herman
Amelie Jacobs (Irene Molloy)
Frankie Leoni (Charlie Brown)
Rocco Leoni (Boq)
Jake Levy
(Jack Kelly)
Nathalia Mendoza
(Alyssa Greene)
Mason Olshavsky (Peter Parker)
Elizabeth Ritacco (Anastasia)
Carrie St. Louis (Glinda)
Noah Sucato (Dr. Pomatter)
Ayden Weinstein
(Marty McFly)
Brielle Diaz Withers (Heather Chandler)

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Past Performances

  • Sun, Mar 17 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map