Skip to main content

Welcome

To
54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

A dark blue, starry sky with a crescent moon sets the stage for white text that reads

What If? Broadway Characters Sing Songs They’re Not Supposed To- Part 6

June 1, 2025

What if Jenna Hunterson sang the Grammy winning song “Slim Pickins” by Sabrina Carpenter, about not being able to find a good man for herself? What if Elphaba and Glinda sang “I Will Never Leave You” from Side Show, right before they said their goodbyes forever? Join us for an exciting evening of What Ifs as your favorite characters sing songs that they’ve never sung before, all while interacting with characters that they usually never get the chance to speak to. Come see familiar and new faces, from Broadway and beyond, sing unexpected combinations of the most beloved musicals in our sixth installment of this series, while you ponder the question, What If?…

Created and music directed by Jorden Amir.

Featuring:

Faith Alhadeff (Sally Bowles)
Angelina Amato (Young Allie)
Jordan Barrow (Boq)
Bryson Battle (Seymour)
Kaileigh Fiorillo (Regina George)
Ellie Fishman (The Baker’s Wife)
Isabela Garcia (Heather McNamara)
Catie Gorton (Natalie Goodman)
Callie Henrysen (Karen Smith)
Grace Hodgett-Young (Eurydice)
Cooper LaMontagne (Young Noah)
Lizzy Legregin (Gretchen Wieners)
Isabel Leoni (Heather Chandler)
Abby McDonough (Queenie)
Juliette Ojeda (Heather Duke)
Mikayla Renfrow (Cinderella)
Nadia Jewel Vito (Audrey)
Ayden Weinstein (Gabe Goodman)
Alyssa Wray (Rizzo)
Maeve Zamuner (Zoe Murphy)

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Featuring

Faith Alhadeff

More
A young person with tousled brown hair smiles at the camera. They have fair skin, brown eyes, and wear a blue collared shirt. The background is a plain, light-colored wall, and the lighting is even.

Jorden Amir

Creator/MD
More
A young woman, Angelina Amato, with wavy brown hair featuring light blonde highlights at the front poses against a deep red background. She has brown eyes, a small hoop nose ring, hoop earrings, and wears a delicate necklace. Her expression is neutral and direct.

Angelina Amato

More

Jordan Barrow

More
A young person with short hair smiles warmly at the camera. Bryson Battle has medium brown skin with visible patches of lighter skin on their face and forehead. They wear a light green t-shirt and are posed against a dark, softly blurred background.

Bryson Battle

More
With long blonde hair and blue eyes, the woman in a lavender knit sweater poses against a solid pink background. Her right hand gently touches her face as she gazes calmly at the camera with a soft smile, reminiscent of an Ethan Jih-Cook portrait. Her makeup subtly emphasizes her eyes and lips.

Kaileigh Fiorillo

More
Ellie Fishman, with long wavy red hair and green eyes, smiles softly at the camera. She wears natural makeup and a black top. The background is a textured teal color.

Ellie Fishman

More

Isabela Garcia

More
A young woman, Catie Gorton, with long, wavy blonde hair and blue eyes smiles warmly. She wears a blue off-the-shoulder top and a delicate necklace with a small, dark pendant against a softly blurred, dark gray studio backdrop.

Catie Gorton

More

Callie Henrysen

More

Grace Hodgett Young

More
Young man with short, wavy brown hair and blue eyes, wearing a dark, washed-out T-shirt. He smiles slightly, looking directly at the camera against a gray background. The subtle lighting showcases his features akin to an Isabel Leoni portrait.

Cooper LaMontagne

More
Maeve Zamuner, a smiling woman with long, dark hair, stands against a dark purple background. She wears a purple top and gold hoop earrings. Her makeup is natural, featuring subtle eye shadow and striking red lipstick.

Lizzy Legregin

More
Isabel Leoni, with her long, curly brown hair and highlights, poses confidently. She wears a black sleeveless top and has one arm behind her head. The soft lighting and neutral background highlight her relaxed, natural expression and features.

Isabel Leoni

More
Abby McDonough, a woman with long brown hair and a neutral expression, wears a sleeveless navy blue outfit with white pinstripes. Positioned slightly to the side against a plain white background, she looks directly at the camera, her hair falling naturally around her shoulders.

Abby McDonough

More

Juliette Ojeda

More

Mikayla Renfrow

More
A woman with long, straight blonde hair and light blue eyes gazes directly at the camera. She has fair skin, subtle makeup, and wears a sleeveless black halter top. The background is a solid, textured dark blue.

Nadia Jewel Vito

More
Ayden Weinstein, a young man with tousled brown hair and blue eyes, gazes at the camera. He wears a light brown suede jacket over a black top. The dark background accentuates his features.

Ayden Weinstein

More

Alyssa Wray

More
Maeve Zamuner, with long brown hair, leans against a white brick wall. Her right arm rests on her head as she gazes softly at the camera. She wears a white top with lace trim, gold hoop earrings, a delicate necklace, and an unobtrusive bracelet on her arm.

Maeve Zamuner

More

Past Performances

  • Sun, Jun 1 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map
The image features the logo of "54 Below," a renowned cabaret and dining club. The logo uses an elegant serif font with the number "54" prominently displayed and the word "BELOW" situated underneath. The text is gold on a dark brown background with a gold border surrounding the design.
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognizing you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.