Skip to main content

Welcome

To
54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

A dark, starry night sky with a crescent moon on the left and scattered stars on the right. In the center, distressed white text reads: “WHAT IF?” underlined, with “Part 7” written below it.

What If? Part 7: The Songs You Love. Unexpectedly Recast.

July 27, 2026

What if there was a multiverse where Glinda’s meltdown leads her to sing “Someone Gets Hurt” from Mean Girls? Or if Collins from Rent sang a Whitney Houston power ballad to his dying lover? Join us for an exciting evening of What Ifs as your favorite musical characters sing songs that they’ve never sung before, all while interacting with characters from different shows. Come support this Broadway Cares/Equity Fights Aids fundraiser event, as you see familiar and new faces, from Broadway and beyond, sing unexpected combinations of the most beloved musicals in our seventh installment of this iconic series, while you ponder the question, What If?…

A portion of the proceeds will benefit BC/EFA.

Created and music directed by Jorden Amir.

Co-produced by Angelina Amato and Cooper LaMontagne.

Featuring:

Bella Aboulhosn (Star to Be)
Faith Alhadeff (Norma Desmond)
Angelina Amato (Mimi Marquez)
Bryson Battle (Tom Collins)
Carissa Gaughran (Annabeth Chase)
Callie Henrysen (Karen Smith)
Sarah Isola (Glinda)
Cooper LaMontagne (Roger Davis)
Michael Moretti (Jack Singer)
Ava Newman (Anna)
Mason Olshavsky (Percy Jackson)
Skyler Reed Lipkind (Kristoff)
Adi Roy (Aladdin)
Cole Thompson (Jack)
Zalah Vallien (Elphaba)
Alyssa Wray (Maureen)
and more stars to be announced!

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Featuring

Bella Aboulhosn, a young woman with long, wavy brown hair, smiles gently. She has blue eyes, natural makeup, and wears a white top with a silver heart pendant necklace. She stands indoors against a neutral background with soft lighting.

Bella Aboulhosn

More
A young woman with wavy, light brown and blonde hair looks over her left shoulder. She has fair skin, natural makeup, and wears a pink top with lace trim. The style is reminiscent of Taylor Leccese against a plain, light beige background.

Faith Alhadeff

More
A young man with tousled brown hair and fair skin smiles softly at the camera. He is wearing a green collared shirt and is posed against a plain, light background. The mood is casual and friendly.

Jorden Amir

Creator/MD
More
A young woman, Angelina Amato, with wavy brown hair featuring light blonde highlights at the front poses against a deep red background. She has brown eyes, a small hoop nose ring, hoop earrings, and wears a delicate necklace. Her expression is neutral and direct.

Angelina Amato

Co-Producer
More
A young person with short hair smiles warmly at the camera. Bryson Battle has medium brown skin with visible patches of lighter skin on their face and forehead. They wear a light green t-shirt and are posed against a dark, softly blurred background.

Bryson Battle

More
A woman, resembling Carissa Gaughran, with wavy, shoulder-length dark brown hair poses against a dark background. She has light skin, hazel eyes, subtle makeup, and a black sleeveless top with lace straps. She softly smiles at the camera.

Carissa Gaughran

More

Callie Henrysen

More
Young woman with long, wavy brown hair wearing a black lace top and a gold necklace with a turquoise pendant. She has light makeup with peach-toned lipstick. Her expression is calm and the background is softly blurred in neutral tones, highlighting her features.

Sarah Isola

More
Young man with short, wavy brown hair and blue eyes, wearing a dark, washed-out T-shirt. He smiles slightly, looking directly at the camera against a gray background. The subtle lighting showcases his features akin to an Isabel Leoni portrait.

Cooper LaMontagne

Co-Producer
More

Michael Moretti

More
A young woman with long, wavy brown hair and fair skin poses against a plain gray background. She wears a dark tank top, looking directly at the camera with a gentle smile and bright green eyes. Her expression is confident and friendly.

Ava Newman

More

Mason Olshavsky

More
Skyler Reed Lipkind, a young person with curly brown hair and blue eyes, looks into the camera with a neutral expression. They wear a red shirt under a blue denim jacket against a plain, light gray background.

Skyler Reed Lipkind

More
Salena Qureshi, with short black hair, gazes directly at the camera wearing a rust-colored jacket over a white top. Her neutral expression is set against a solid blue background, enhancing the contrast of her attire and features.

Adi Roy

More

Cole Thompson

More
Smiling woman with curly brown hair, wearing a teal sleeveless top. Her Zalah Vallien earrings are small hoops, and she's wearing a necklace with two floral charm designs. The background is plain and light-colored, highlighting her cheerful expression.

Zalah Vallien

More
A young woman with long, braided brown hair rests her head on her hand. She has glowing skin, natural makeup with rosy cheeks and glossy lips, and wears a beige top. The background is a soft, muted green. She gazes calmly at the camera.

Alyssa Wray

More

Pricing

  • $19.50 (includes $4.50 in fees) – $52.50 (includes $7.50 in fees)
  • VIP Seating: $63.50 (includes $8.50 in fees)
  • Premiums: $85.50 (includes $10.50 in fees)
  • Prices shown are only valid for online purchases. Additional $6 in fees for all seating sections if purchased at the box office.
  • $25 Food & Beverage Minimum

Times(show / doors open)

Buy Tickets View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map