Skip to main content

Welcome

To
54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

Orange text on a purple background reads, “The Lads Who Lunch,” with a martini glass forming the letter

The Lads Who Lunch: A Sondheim Miscast

October 7, 2025

The Lads Who Lunch: A Sondheim Miscast is a one-night-only concert where performers flip the script and sing Sondheim songs they’d never be cast to sing. It’s a fresh, playful take on his iconic work—celebrating the music while bending the rules. Expect powerful performances, unexpected moments, and a new lens on songs you thought you knew. It’s Sondheim, reimagined and redefined.

Produced by Tori Jeanine, Jackie Maroney, and Rachel Lynne Smith.

Music direction by Joshua Turchin.

Featuring:

Michael Bernardi (Fiddler On The Roof)
Kayleigh Marie Brennan
Christina Britton
John Harmon Cooper (Love Life Encores! New York City Center)
Caitlin Donohue-Bernardi (The Marvelous Wonderettes Off-Broadway, 1001 Nights at the Atlantic Theater Company)
Mary Kate Heagerty
Tori Jeanine
Carly Jerstad
Jake Latts
Jackie Maroney
Rachel Lynne Smith
Troy Tripicchio (Friends! The Musical Parody Off-Broadway)
Abby Wolanin

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Featuring

A man with short, dark hair and a full beard smiles warmly at the camera. He is wearing a navy blazer over a light gray collared shirt. The softly blurred background features hints of indoor lighting and neutral tones, photographed by Abby Wolanin.

Michael Bernardi

More
Kayleigh Brennan, a woman with wavy dark brown hair and blue eyes, looks directly at the camera. She has light skin, subtle makeup, and wears a blue sleeveless top. The warm brown gradient background creates a soft, professional portrait.

Kayleigh Marie Brennan

More
A smiling woman with straight, chin-length blonde hair and bangs wears a bright pink collared shirt. She has fair skin, light-colored eyes, and small, gold, square-shaped earrings. The background is plain and softly lit in warm beige tones.

Christina Britton

More
A young Black man with short hair and a trimmed mustache and goatee looks directly at the camera. He is wearing a light beige sweater and stands against a dark green, softly blurred background. The lighting is even, highlighting his facial features.

John Harmon Cooper

More

Caitlin Donohue-Bernardi

More
A young woman with long brown hair, resembling Abby Wolanin, looks directly at the camera. She has brown eyes, natural makeup, and wears a black top. The simple dark background keeps the focus on her neutral, expressive face.

Mary Kate Heagerty

More
Abby Wolanin, with wavy auburn hair, smiles softly. She wears bold blue and black winged eyeshadow, pink lipstick, a silver necklace, and a striped top. The background reveals part of a painting with trees and water in a softly lit room.

Tori Jeanine

Producer
More
A young woman with long wavy strawberry-blonde hair and freckles smiles gently at the camera. She wears a sleeveless teal top and is standing in front of a softly blurred gray background. Soft lighting highlights her natural features.

Carly Jerstad

More
A young man with short dark hair and trimmed facial hair smiles warmly at the camera. He wears a light blue button-up shirt and stands in front of a blurred brick wall background. The lighting is natural and even.

Jake Latts

More

Jackie Maroney

Producer
More
A young woman, Abby Wolanin, with medium-length dark brown hair parted slightly to the side, wearing a sleeveless black top. She has a small nose ring and neutral makeup, looking directly at the camera with a subtle, confident expression against a plain gray background.

Rachel Lynne Smith

Producer
More
A young man with short curly black hair, light brown skin, and a trimmed beard looks directly at the camera. He wears a black jacket over a gray shirt. The blurred background, bright with sunlight and tall buildings, echoes Abby Wolanin’s urban energy.

Troy Tripicchio

More

Joshua Turchin

Music Director
More
Abby Wolanin, with straight dark brown hair pulled back, wearing hoop earrings and a red top, smiles at the camera. The background features green trees and sunlight, suggesting an outdoor setting.

Abby Wolanin

More

Past Performances

  • Tue, Oct 7 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map