Skip to main content

Welcome

To
54 Below

A Nonprofit Cabaret Venue

Bright pink background with diagonal rows of yellow and white dots framing the edges. Large white text in the center reads, “MY BROADWAY IDOL.” Smaller yellow text below says, “A tribute to the Broadway stars that inspire us.”.

My Broadway Idol – A Tribute to the Stars that Inspire Us

December 1, 2025

What do Audra McDonald, Bernadette Peters, Kristin Chenoweth, Joshua Henry, Julie Andrews, Barbra Streisand, Eva Noblezada, and Aaron Tveit all have in common?

They are Broadway Idols who have inspired generations of performers! Enjoy a heartfelt and high-energy night where rising stars and seasoned performers take the stage to pay tribute to their heroes. Produced by Katy Manderfeld, with music direction by Joseph Thor and featuring iconic numbers from shows like Wicked, Funny Girl, Hadestown, Ragtime, and Carousel, the night will showcase songs that span generations of musical theatre. Whether you’re a lifelong theater buff or a Broadway newcomer, this will be a show you don’t want to miss!

Featuring:

Gavin Blonda
Blake Brundy
Brevan Collins
Amelia Diaz
Sydney Freihofer
Jake Goodman
Daphny Gualberto
Abigail Hammond
Emma Luxemburg
Katy Manderfeld
Michael Mariniello
Maya Marino Cappello
Dayven Martinez
Emiliano Pliego
Joseph Pyfferoen
Yasmin Ranz-Lind
Anna Sprau
Joseph Thor
Lauren Torey
Sophie Joan Tyler

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Featuring

A young person, Katy Manderfeld, with short, light brown hair and blue eyes faces the camera against a dark blue background. They wear a denim jacket over a gray shirt and have a neutral, calm expression. Soft lighting highlights their features evenly.

Gavin Blonda

More
A man with short dark hair, a full reddish-brown beard, and a mustache is facing forward, smiling slightly. He has light eyes and wears a dark collared shirt. The background is a solid dark teal color, reminiscent of Katy Manderfeld’s style.

Blake Brundy

More
Brevan Collins, a person with short light brown hair and fair skin, smiles softly at the camera. They wear a green shirt and a thin gold necklace, with small earrings visible. The solid warm orange background provides a perfect contrast to their outfit and features.

Brevan Collins

More
A young woman with long, wavy dark hair smiles brightly at the camera. She wears hoop earrings and layered bead necklaces. Her skin is smooth and she has natural makeup. The background is a plain, neutral gray, highlighting Katy Manderfeld’s vibrant style.

Amelia Diaz

More
Sydney Freihofer, a young person with short, tousled brown hair and bangs, smiles warmly. With fair skin and brown eyes, they wear light makeup and a sleeveless light blue denim top over a beige shirt against a plain tan background.

Sydney Freihofer

More
Portrait of a young person with short dark hair, looking directly at the camera. They wear a light blue jacket over a white t-shirt. Set against a soft blue background, which complements their attire, Makayla Baxter's expression is neutral, conveying a calm and relaxed demeanor.

Jake Goodman

More
A young woman with long, straight brown hair and a calm expression looks slightly past the camera. Katy Manderfeld wears a lavender top and stands outdoors near a stone railing and bright pink flowers, with blurred buildings in the background.

Daphny Gualberto

More
A young woman, Katy Manderfeld, with long, straight red hair and fair skin looks directly at the camera. She wears gold hoop earrings, a white top, and blue denim overalls against a soft beige background. Her expression is neutral and relaxed.

Abigail Hammond

More
Katy Manderfeld, with wavy, shoulder-length auburn hair and blue eyes, faces the camera with a neutral expression. She wears gold flower-shaped earrings and a navy top against a plain, olive green background, softly and evenly lit.

Emma Luxemburg

More
A young woman with short, blonde hair and blue eyes smiles softly at the camera. Wearing a blue off-the-shoulder top, Katy Manderfeld’s subtle, natural makeup stands out against the solid light pink background, giving the portrait a cheerful feel.

Katy Manderfeld

Producer
More
A young man with short dark hair and fair skin looks directly at the camera. He wears a black sleeveless top. The plain, dark background highlights his features and neutral expression, while the soft lighting creates a style reminiscent of Lauren Torey.

Michael Mariniello

More
Lauren Torey smiles brightly, showing her teeth. A young woman with natural curly black hair, she wears a sleeveless, ribbed red top and has dramatic eyelashes. The background is a plain, light-colored wall.

Maya Marino Cappello

More
A young person with short, dark, tightly curled hair and thick eyebrows looks directly at the camera with a neutral expression. Lauren Torey is wearing a black crew-neck shirt and is posed against a plain white background.

Dayven Martinez

More
August Miller, with short, neatly styled hair and a neutral expression, dons a cream-colored sweater under brown overalls. The solid purple background adds depth to his understated style.

Emiliano Pliego

More
Lauren Torey, with fair skin, short light brown hair, and light-colored eyes behind rectangular black glasses, smiles softly. Dressed in a brown jacket over a purple shirt, she stands against a blurred dark green background.

Joseph Pyfferoen

More
Eleni Kontzamanys, a woman with long, curly brown hair, dons a blue tank top against a plain gray background. Her head is slightly tilted as she smiles softly, exuding a neutral and relaxed demeanor. The even lighting accentuates her features and the texture of her hair beautifully.

Yasmin Ranz-Lind

More
Lauren Torey, a young woman with long brown hair and blue eyes, smiles softly. She wears a light green top, gold hoop earrings, layered gold necklaces, and natural makeup with pink lipstick against a solid magenta background.

Anna Sprau

More
A young man with short dark hair and pale skin tilts his head slightly and looks confidently at the camera. He wears a dark brown textured shirt. The background is a solid dark green, in the distinctive style of Lauren Torey. Even lighting highlights his features.

Joseph Thor

Music Director
More
Lauren Torey, a woman with long brown hair and bangs wearing a blue top, poses in front of a dark background. She smiles slightly, resting her chin on her hand and looking directly at the camera with a calm expression.

Lauren Torey

More
Kyra Kennedy, with short, textured brown hair and bold eyebrows, poses against a maroon background. She wears a white sleeveless top, gold hoop earrings, and rings, her hands gently framing her face with a neutral, slightly parted lip expression.

Sophie Joan Tyler

More

Past Performances

  • Mon, Dec 1 :9:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map
The image features the logo of "54 Below," a renowned cabaret and dining club. The logo uses an elegant serif font with the number "54" prominently displayed and the word "BELOW" situated underneath. The text is gold on a dark brown background with a gold border surrounding the design.
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognizing you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.